Where flavors meet
Welcome to Next Door Pub & Pizzeria
Next Door Pub & Pizzeria, located at 411 Interchange N in Lake Geneva, WI, is a beloved hotspot known for its family-friendly atmosphere and delicious offerings. Guests rave about the best pizza in the area, as well as mouthwatering dishes like the grilled cheese and Lakeside Salad, featuring generous portions of salmon. The staff exudes warmth and hospitality, making every visit feel like a vacation. With a lively ambiance enhanced by friendly service and a clean environment, it's no wonder that patrons from afar, including those from Illinois, return time and again. Don’t miss out on the cheesy spinach artichoke flatbread and delectable garlic knots!
Taste the best
Discover Menu
Pub Wings
US$20.95Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
Starry Zero Sugar
Mug Root Beer
Mountain Dew
Dr. Pepper
Tropicana Lemonade
$0Brisk Raspberry Iced Tea
$0Strawberry Lemonade
$0 Inside the Experience
Next Door Pub & Pizzeria
Welcome to Next Door Pub & Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious food and a warm, inviting atmosphere right in the heart of Lake Geneva, WI. Located at 411 Interchange N, we pride ourselves on being more than just a pizzeria; we are a community gathering spot where families, friends, and visitors come together to enjoy mouthwatering meals.
Our customers rave about their experiences here, with reviews highlighting everything from our friendly staff to the tantalizing flavors of our dishes. Ann Bliss shared how her carryout was not only “delicious” but that our team provided service with a smile, making her wish she had dined in with our vibrant crowd. With prices that won’t break the bank, we offer an enjoyable experience for everyone.
Steven McHugh couldn’t get enough of our grilled cheese, calling it “amazing” and suggesting that visiting us feels like being with family on vacation. That's the atmosphere we're proud to foster. Barry Benecke even travels over an hour from Illinois because he knows our pizza is a must-try, alongside the countless compliments we receive for our friendly service and inviting environment.
At Next Door Pub & Pizzeria, you can savor our flavorful Lakeside Salad, which received high praise from Donna S, or indulge in our delectable Southwest grilled chicken sandwich. We cater to every palate, from veggie lovers to meat enthusiasts. Kristine Nelson highlighted the excitement of taking in a game at the bar while enjoying our top-notch pizza, emphasizing the perfect pairing of great food and entertainment.
Apart from the great food and cozy ambience, we excel in our organizational service. Jen Woodrum praised our seamless curbside pickup process, and Kyle Drilling appreciated the cold beer and good service during a busy evening with friends. Our commitment to quick, efficient service means you won’t have to wait long to enjoy the culinary delights we offer.
Whether you are stopping by for a casual family dinner or planning a night out with friends, Next Door Pub & Pizzeria is always the perfect choice. Our doors are open, welcoming you to experience the best pizza in Lake Geneva and much more. Come join us soon and taste the heart of our community!
Stories & Reviews
Guestbook
“ Ordered some carryout on a girls weekend & it was delicious! The prices were reasonable. When we picked it up staff was polite & friendly. The place was popping & we almost wished we had dined in. ”
“ Awesome experience all around!! Tried the grilled cheese/it was amazing!! Everything about this place feels like family, and vacation! Totally worth it and the best pizza in the area!! We will be back for more!! ”
“ Our frequent stop when going to Lake Geneva. This visit I had the Lakeside Salad which had a generous piece of salmon. My husband had the Southwest grilled chicken sandwich which had grilled veggies and cheese and fresh pub chips. Our waitress Kathy was very nice! ”
“ We were on the area and ended eating here and we loved it . Came with my family and we had a pleasant dinner, service was great the food came out fast and the restroom were clean as well as the rest of the restaurant. ”
“ We drove over an hour from our suburb in Illinois, for their pizza. We also visit the town of Lake Geneva while up there, but Next Door Pub & Pizzeria is always our destination when we go. It was so busy on one of our visits, that we had to order our pizza to go. Usually though, we are able to get seated fairly quickly. We can't wait to check out there second location. We invited our friends to join us, and they loved it as well! ”